These are my 10 best Christmas cookies, the ones I bake every single December. Some are classics that earned their spot years ago, and some are newer favorites I can’t stop baking. Every one is tested in my own kitchen, and every one is a cookie I’d be proud to hand you.

I’ve baked a lot of Christmas cookies over the years. Too many to fit on one plate, if I’m being realistic. So I asked myself a simple question: if I could only bake ten this year, which ones would make the cut?
This summer I baked all of my Christmas cookies early so I could photograph them all together, like a huge Christmas cookie smorgasbord. When the shoot was done, I invited local friends and family over for a Christmas in July party. We celebrated my 400th post going live, did a white elephant gift exchange, and everyone tasted the cookies and voted for their favorites.
This is that list. It’s my killer Christmas cookie lineup, and it’s a little bit about me. These are the cookies my family asks for, the ones friends text, call and email me for, and the ones I’d pick every time. At the bottom you’ll find five more I love too much to leave out. (I may have a cookie problem, but I don’t have a problem with that.)
My 10 Best Christmas Cookies
Below you’ll find a quick guide to help you choose, then all ten cookies with a photo and a few words about why each one made the list. At the end there are tips for baking ahead, building a Christmas cookie plate, and a peek behind the scenes.

Which Christmas Cookie Should You Make?
| Cookie | Best for | Chill time | Makes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cherry Blossom Cookies | Something people haven’t tried | None | 28 cookies |
| Chewy Snickerdoodles | Cinnamon lovers and kids | 2 hours | 36 cookies |
| Peanut Butter Blossoms | Peanut butter and chocolate fans | 1 hour | 24 cookies |
| Soft Cut Out Sugar Cookies | Decorating | None | 36 cookies |
| Double Chocolate Crinkle Cookies | Chocolate lovers | About 2 hours | 24 cookies |
| Easy Turtle Bars | Feeding a crowd | None | 48 bars |
| Soft Chewy Sugar Cookies | Rolling in sprinkles with kids | None | 29 cookies |
| Soft Ginger Cookies | Making ahead | 30 minutes (freezer) | 56 cookies |
| Chewy Marzipan Cookies | Almond lovers | 2 hours | 27 cookies |
| Easy Scottish Shortbread | Just 4 ingredients | None | 24 fingers |
1. Cherry Blossom Cookies: My Number One
If I could only bake one Christmas cookie, it would be this one. These sweet, chewy sugar cookies are full of maraschino cherry bits and a hint of almond, then topped with a chocolate Kiss or a whole cherry.
People always ask, “What are these?” You don’t see many cherry cookies, and these fly off the plate. There’s no chilling, so you can have a batch out of the oven in about 20 minutes.
2. Chewy Snickerdoodles: All Butter, Extra Cinnamon
These snickerdoodles are soft and chewy, made with all butter and rolled in a thick coat of cinnamon sugar. The details matter in a classic cookie, and these get every one right.
They won first place at my Christmas in July cookie vote. Friends and family tasted every cookie at the party, and snickerdoodles got the most votes. Cherry blossom cookies came in right behind, with Scottish shortbread in third. Snickerdoodles are one of my kids’ very top picks. Only cherry blossom cookies beat them.
3. Peanut Butter Blossoms: A Christmas Classic
Soft, chewy peanut butter cookies rolled in sugar and topped with a chocolate Kiss. I make mine with all butter, and brown sugar gives them a deeper flavor.
My kids ask for these every year. A quick one-hour chill keeps them thick. You can also freeze the dough balls and bake them later.
4. Soft Cut Out Sugar Cookies: No Chill Needed
I baked hundreds of test cookies to get this recipe right. The dough is ready to roll in minutes, and the cookies hold their shape in the oven, so your trees still look like trees. These are a reader favorite, too. They’ve been one of my top 10 posts almost every year since I first shared them in 2015.
They’re perfect for decorating with kids at Christmas. Pair them with my buttercream frosting for sugar cookies. It’s easy to pipe and tastes as good as it looks.
5. Double Chocolate Crinkle Cookies: Snowy and Fudgy
Cocoa and chocolate chips make these crinkle cookies soft and fudgy inside. A thick coat of powdered sugar cracks open in the oven for that snowy, crackly top.
The classics are classics for a reason. My kids adore these, and I think the powdered sugar is half the fun. (A little mess just makes a cookie better when you’re a kid.) Anything that brings my kids joy brings me joy too.
6. Easy Turtle Bars: Chocolate, Caramel and Pecans
A buttery shortbread crust, gooey caramel full of pecans and a thick layer of chocolate on top. When I want a chocolate and caramel cookie, these are it. There’s nothing else like them.
They start with a shortcut: store-bought caramels. The little square caramels melt into a quick caramel sauce, so these look fancy but they’re ridiculously easy. One pan makes 48 bars, which is perfect for a cookie exchange or a holiday party. Any nut you like works here.
7. Soft Chewy Sugar Cookies: Roll Them in Sprinkles
Buttery sugar cookies with crackly tops, chewy centers and just a little crisp at the edges. Roll the dough balls in sugar, golden raw sugar or red and green sprinkles.
These are the cookies we bake when the tree goes up. There’s no chilling and no rolling pin, so kids can help with every step.
8. Soft Ginger Cookies: Old Fashioned Flavor
This recipe came from my Great Aunt Ruth in St. Paul, Minnesota, and she made them just right. Before her, I didn’t know how much I loved ginger cookies. The warm spices, the chew and the icing drizzle add up to the perfect Christmas cookie.
They’re perfect for baking ahead. Freeze the dough and bake a few at a time, so you can have warm cookies whenever company drops by.
9. Chewy Marzipan Cookies: For Almond Lovers
My grandmother gave me little marzipan treats when I was growing up, and I’ve loved almond flavor ever since. These cookies are lightly crisp outside with a soft, chewy middle.
They add something different to a Christmas cookie plate. Make them with homemade or store-bought marzipan. They’re egg-free, too.
10. Easy Scottish Shortbread: Just 4 Ingredients
My grandmother used to bring shortbread fingers when she visited from Minnesota. They were buttery and crumbly and melted in your mouth. Now I make them with butter, powdered sugar, flour and a sprinkle of sugar on top.
Shortbread is the perfect crisp cookie. You pat the dough into one pan, bake, cut and let it cool in the oven. It tastes fresher than anything from a tin, and it costs a fraction of the price.
5 More Christmas Cookies I Love
Ten wasn’t quite enough. These five are on my Christmas baking list most years too.

Oatmeal Rum Raisin Cookies: Soft oatmeal cookie bars with brown butter, toasted pecans and raisins soaked in spiced rum. A cozy, grown-up treat for the holidays.

Anise Cookies: Soft, buttery old fashioned cookies with a hint of licorice flavor. My parents’ and grandparents’ generations remember them as a treasured Christmas cookie.

No Chill Chocolate Sugar Cookies: Rich chocolate cut out cookies that roll out without sticking and hold their shape. Cut them into trees, stars or gingerbread men.

Christmas M&M Cookie Bars: Thick, chewy cookie bars full of red and green M&Ms. One bowl and one pan, so they’re perfect for a busy week.

Extra Zesty Lemon Sugar Cookies: Soft and chewy, with lemon zest, fresh lemon juice and lemon oil. A bright, fresh bite next to all the chocolate on the plate.
Tips for Baking Christmas Cookies Ahead
December gets busy. Here’s how I spread out my Christmas baking so I’m not up until midnight the week of Christmas.
- Start with the no chill cookies. Cherry blossom cookies, shortbread, soft chewy sugar cookies and turtle bars can go from bowl to oven right away.
- Freeze dough balls. Ginger cookie, peanut butter blossom and soft chewy sugar cookie dough all freeze well. Bake a tray whenever you need fresh cookies.
- Bake and freeze. Shortbread keeps in the freezer for up to 3 months, and baked soft chewy sugar cookies freeze well too.
- Frost cut out cookies close to serving. Bake them ahead, then frost them no more than about 3 days before you serve them. That’s how long they taste their best once the frosting goes on.
How to Build a Christmas Cookie Plate
A pretty cookie plate is mostly about mixing things up. Here’s what I aim for.

- Mix colors. Pair dark cookies like crinkles and turtle bars with light ones like shortbread and sugar cookies.
- Mix textures. Put crisp shortbread next to soft, chewy cookies.
- Add something unexpected. Cherry blossom, marzipan or anise cookies get people talking.
- Tuck in a little candy. A few squares of homemade fudge or easy homemade caramels make the plate feel extra special.
Behind the Scenes: My 400th Post Christmas Cookie Shoot
This list comes from a big moment for me. A blog post usually takes more than 12 hours of work, and this summer I hit 400 of them. That’s more than 4,800 hours of baking, testing, photographing and writing. To celebrate, we turned it into one giant Christmas cookie shoot.

It took the whole family. Jon helped me set up, and Jack helped with a little bit of everything. He was my dishes hero! Ella helped with the styling. She’s starting to learn how food styling works, and it was so neat to work on it together.


Joseph was my official cookie taster, and his opinions are pretty solid. If you want to know what makes a good cookie, ask a little kid. At the very end, I climbed a ladder to get the overhead shots.


Which Christmas Cookie Will You Bake First?
Whether you want a classic, something chocolate or a cookie nobody’s tried before, there’s one here for you. Pick a favorite, bake a batch and share it with someone you love this Christmas.
Want even more ideas? See my big list of easy Christmas cookie recipes.
I always tuck a few homemade candies onto my cookie platters, too. It’s such a delightful touch. Here are my favorite fudge recipes and my easy Christmas candy recipes to get you started.










Leave a Reply