These are the Christmas candy recipes I make every December: soft caramels, peppermint bark, three kinds of fudge, retro jelly nougat and more. Most of them don’t need a candy thermometer, and several are ready in about 10 minutes. If you’re looking for Christmas candy ideas that a beginner can pull off, you’re in the right place.

Homemade candy is one of my favorite parts of Christmas. Growing up, my cousin made huge tins of candy every year, and I couldn’t wait for her big candy plate. When I was in high school, she got me started on fudge making, and I’ve been making candy ever since.
Now I fill tins for neighbors, teachers and friends, and I tuck a few pieces onto every cookie plate. These homemade Christmas candy recipes are the ones I come back to year after year. Every one is tested in my own kitchen, and every one is easy enough for a first-timer.
Easy Christmas Candy Recipes for Gifts and Cookie Plates
Below you’ll find a quick guide to help you choose, then all ten candies with a photo and a few words about each one. At the end there are tips for making candy, giving it as gifts and making it ahead.
Which Christmas Candy Should You Make?
| Candy | Best for | Candy thermometer? | Makes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Peppermint Oreo Bark | Making candy with kids | No | 40 squares |
| Fantasy Fudge | A big batch for sharing | No | 96 squares |
| Jelly Nougat Candy | A retro favorite | No | 60 pieces |
| Easy Chocolate Truffles | Something fancy | No | 48 truffles |
| Easy Chocolate Peanut Butter Fudge | Peanut butter lovers | No | 32 squares |
| Easy Homemade Marzipan | Almond lovers | No | About 13 ounces |
| Fast and Easy Fudge | A last-minute treat | No | 32 squares |
| Lightly Candied Pecans | Quick gifts | No | 6 servings |
| Easy Homemade Caramels | Learning to use a candy thermometer | Yes | 72 caramels |
| Candied Citrus Peel | Old fashioned flavor | No | 1 to 2 cups |
1. Easy Homemade Caramels: Soft, Chewy and Forgiving
These caramels are soft, chewy and rich with butter. A little flour and cornstarch go in at the very end, and they make this recipe more forgiving than most. The caramels set up soft and chewy every time.
It’s the perfect recipe for learning to use a candy thermometer. You cook the caramel low and slow to 235°F while it turns a deep amber. My boys are nuts about these. I always stash a bag in the freezer for later, but somehow they’re gone before later comes.
2. Peppermint Oreo Bark: Four Ingredients
Rich semi-sweet chocolate with crunchy Oreos stirred right in and a thick layer of crushed candy cane on top. It takes about 15 minutes of hands-on time, and the fridge does the rest.
Kids love helping with this one. Smashing the Oreos with a rolling pin is my kids’ favorite part. (It’s a pretty good stress reliever for me during Christmas prep, too!) Cut it into squares for gift bags and cookie exchanges. (Yes, I know bark isn’t a cookie. But it has cookies in it, so it counts on a technicality.)
3. Fantasy Fudge: The Classic Christmas Fudge
A big pan of creamy chocolate fudge made with melted marshmallows, so there’s no candy thermometer to watch. One batch makes 96 squares, with plenty to share.
This is the fudge I grew up on. It’s the one my cousin made every Christmas and taught me to make in high school. She even made a big platter of it for our wedding reception. It’s a tradition we never skip.
4. Jelly Nougat Candy: A Retro 10-Minute Favorite
Soft, chewy white nougat full of colorful gumdrops, so each slice looks like a little stained-glass window. It takes about 10 minutes and a microwave, and you don’t need any candy-making experience.
If you remember Brach’s jelly nougat, this one’s for you. My dad loved them, and we ate them together all the time. After they were discontinued, I missed them enough to make my own. Now I get to share them with my kids and with friends who remember them, too.
5. Easy Chocolate Truffles: A Few Simple Ingredients
Smooth, creamy milk chocolate truffles with plenty of almond extract. They take just a few simple ingredients, and they melt in your mouth.
These were always on my cousin’s Christmas candy plates. I’ve been making them about as long as I can remember. A small scoop makes rolling them quick, and they’re a delightful little treat to tuck into a gift box.
6. Easy Chocolate Peanut Butter Fudge: About 15 Minutes
Thick, creamy fudge with chocolate and peanut butter in every bite. You boil granulated sugar and milk for 2 minutes, then whisk in chocolate chips and peanut butter. There’s no candy thermometer and no sweetened condensed milk.
If you’ve never made candy before, start here. This is my “I worked all day, dinner was a flop, I want a treat now” recipe. It sets up in a loaf pan and makes a thoughtful gift for the peanut butter lovers on your list.
7. Easy Homemade Marzipan: No Cooking at All
Sweet, smooth and full of almond flavor. Homemade marzipan takes four ingredients, a food processor and about five minutes of work, with no candy thermometer.
My grandmother loved marzipan. She often brought me little boxes of it shaped like strawberries. Now I make my own, and it’s much cheaper than the little tubes at the store. Shape it into fruits or holiday shapes, or bake it into my chewy marzipan cookies.
8. Fast and Easy Fudge: My Emergency Fudge
Brown sugar, vanilla and a pinch of salt give this easy fudge a deep, rich chocolate flavor. It takes about 10 minutes of hands-on time, with no candy thermometer and no condensed milk.
This is my “emergency” fudge. Need a treat for a party tomorrow? You can have a pan of homemade fudge setting in about 10 minutes. It’s so simple that my kids could help when they were really little.
9. Lightly Candied Pecans: Ready in 5 Minutes
Pecans cooked on the stove with butter, brown sugar and a little salt, for a light, sweet crunch. They take about five minutes, and there’s no egg white, so they’re egg-free.
They make an easy last-minute gift. I also love setting out a bowl of them with desserts like carrot cake and pie, and they’re delicious on salads.
10. Candied Citrus Peel: An Old Fashioned Treat
Strips of orange or lemon peel simmered in sugar syrup, dried, then rolled in granulated sugar. The flavor is bright and strong, so a little piece goes a long way. Serve it on a candy plate, dip it in dark chocolate or use it to garnish a special drink.
This one always makes me think of my grandmother. When she came to visit, her suitcases were full of fancy chocolate, marzipan and candied citrus peel. She favored orange. I like lemon best.
Old Fashioned Christmas Candy
Some Christmas candy is worth making just for the memories. If you love old fashioned Christmas candy, these are the ones that take me back.
- Jelly nougat: the soft, gumdrop-studded candy so many of us remember from a tin of mixed Christmas candy at Grandma’s house.
- Fantasy fudge: my cousin’s recipe came from the old Kraft Fantasy Fudge recipe, and it’s still the fudge I make every Christmas.
- Candied citrus peel: a classic treat for a candy plate, and a little taste of my grandmother’s kitchen.
- Marzipan: a staple of European baking traditions, especially in Germany, and easy to make at home.
Christmas Candy Gifts
Homemade candy makes such a thoughtful Christmas gift. So few people make it at home anymore, and it shows you took the time. Here’s how I pack up the candies on this list.
- Caramels: Wrap each one, then fill a Christmas cookie tin. This year they’re going in my boys’ Christmas stockings.
- Fudge: Layer the squares in a tin with parchment paper between the layers. A big pan of Fantasy Fudge fills several tins for neighbors, teachers and friends.
- Peppermint bark: Cut it into squares and pack it into gift bags, with parchment between the layers.
- Jelly nougat: Wrap each piece in a clear candy wrapper, or separate the layers with wax paper.
- A bigger gift: Tuck a bag of caramel Chex mix next to a tin of caramels.
Add Candy to Your Christmas Cookie Plate
Every cookie plate needs a pop of color and a mix of textures, and a little candy does that beautifully. When I photographed my 10 best Christmas cookies this summer, I tucked wrapped caramels and squares of peppermint bark right in with the cookies.

The red and white bark and the shiny wrapped caramels make the whole plate look more festive. Add a few squares of fudge, and you have a cookie plate that feels extra special.

How to Make Christmas Candy: My Best Tips
Making candy at home is easier than most people think. These tips come straight from my own kitchen.
- Start with a candy that doesn’t need a thermometer. The fudges, peppermint bark, jelly nougat and marzipan are all easy first candies.
- Get a digital candy thermometer with an alarm. For caramels, a few degrees matter. I love my ThermoWorks ChefAlarm, because it reads quickly and beeps when the candy is ready.
- Use good chocolate. Bark and fudge are mostly chocolate, so it makes a big difference. Chocolate has changed a lot in the last few years, and many brands have changed their recipes to keep costs down. Even if you have a favorite brand, taste a chip when you open the bag to make sure it’s still what you expect.
- Grease fudge pans with butter. Fudge picks up the flavor of whatever you grease the pan with, so skip the oil and cooking spray.
- Wear shoes. Hot sugar can burn. When we make candy, I try to remember to check that we’re all wearing shoes, kids included. I don’t always remember, but I do my best. A little common sense goes a long way.
Making Christmas Candy Ahead
Several of these candies freeze beautifully, so you can spread your candy making out over the month.
- Freeze up to 3 months: caramels, Fantasy Fudge (freeze it in big slabs, then cut it after thawing) and marzipan.
- Freeze up to 2 months: jelly nougat. Thaw it in the fridge overnight so it doesn’t get sticky.
- Freeze for several months: lightly candied pecans.
- Make close to Christmas: peppermint bark. It’s best in the first week, and I don’t recommend freezing it.
- Keep in the fridge: Fast and Easy Fudge and chocolate peanut butter fudge keep about 2 weeks in the fridge, or about a week at room temperature.
Bonus: Caramel Chex Mix

Caramel Chex Mix: It isn’t candy, exactly, but this sweet and salty mix tops my list every Christmas. It’s easy to make with kids, and a bag of it makes a perfect gift next to a tin of homemade caramels.
Which Christmas Candy Will You Make First?
Whether you want a classic fudge, a retro favorite or your very first batch of caramels, there’s a candy here for you. Pick one, make a batch and share it with someone you love this Christmas.
Want even more fudge? See all my favorite fudge recipes. And for the rest of your Christmas plate, here are my 10 best Christmas cookies and my big list of easy Christmas cookies.










Leave a Reply