Looking for fudge recipes to make this Christmas? These are the six I make again and again, from a big pan of marshmallow fudge for sharing to a no cook fudge you can mix up in 15 minutes. None of them need a candy thermometer, so there’s a fudge here for every kind of cook.

Fudge used to mean butter and cream cooked on the stove. It came in chocolate, and maybe chocolate with nuts. Now it comes in every flavor you can think up. Years ago I ate Power Bait fudge at Cabela’s in Nevada. Yes, really. Cabela’s is a weird and mysterious store, my friends.
I fell in love with fudge because of an older cousin who was always making it when I was growing up. She really made the best fudge, and her big Christmas candy plates are still my idea of a perfect holiday.
Delicious Fudge Recipes for Christmas
Below you’ll find the four kinds of fudge, a quick guide to help you choose, and my six favorite recipes. At the end there are tips for making fudge ahead and packaging it for gifts.
The 4 Types of Fudge
I think about fudge in four kinds. Each one is a little different, and each has its own pros and cons.
- No Cook fudge never touches the stove. Butter, powdered sugar, cream and melted chocolate get beaten together, pressed into a pan and chilled. It’s the simplest kind there is.
- Easy Cook fudge boils sugar and milk for just a few minutes, then chocolate chips melt in. It’s what I make when I’m having a fudge emergency. (Yes, that’s a real thing.)
- Marshmallow fudge is my favorite. Marshmallows keep it creamy and smooth, so there’s no candy thermometer to watch. It’s the kind my cousin made, and the habit stuck.
- Old Fashioned fudge is cream, butter and sugar cooked to an exact temperature, then beaten until it thickens. My mom likes this kind best, because it’s what she grew up on.
Which Fudge Recipe Should You Make?
| Recipe | Kind | Best for | Makes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fantasy Fudge | Marshmallow | A big batch for sharing | 96 squares |
| Fast & Easy Fudge | Easy Cook | Your very first fudge | 32 squares |
| Chocolate Peanut Butter Fudge | Easy Cook | Peanut butter lovers | 32 squares |
| No Cook Chocolate Walnut Fudge | No Cook | No stove at all | 36 squares |
| Candy Corn Fudge | Easy Cook | Halloween, Christmas or Easter | 32 squares |
| Fudge S’mores | Easy Cook | Campfires and parties | 16 s’mores |
1. Fantasy Fudge: A Big Pan of Creamy Marshmallow Fudge
This is the fudge I grew up on. It’s based on the classic Kraft Fantasy Fudge, and melted marshmallows keep it smooth and creamy every time.
One pan makes 96 squares, so there’s plenty to share. It’s my go-to for Christmas candy plates, and you can make it ahead and freeze it.
2. Fast & Easy Fudge: The Perfect First Fudge
Brown sugar, vanilla and a pinch of salt give this fudge a deep, rich chocolate flavor. It takes about 10 minutes of hands-on time, with no condensed milk.
If you’ve never made candy before, start right here. There’s no thermometer to read and no soft ball stage to guess at.
3. Easy Chocolate Peanut Butter Fudge
Chocolate and peanut butter belong together, and this fudge proves it. It sets up thick and creamy in a loaf pan after about 15 minutes of work.
It makes a thoughtful Christmas gift. Cut it into small squares and tuck them into a tin for a neighbor or teacher.
4. No Cook Chocolate Walnut Fudge: No Stove Required
This rich chocolate walnut fudge mixes up in about 15 minutes without turning on the stove. You beat it together in a stand mixer, press it into a pan and chill it.
It’s my go-to when I need a last-minute treat or gift. Leave out the walnuts if you like. It works the same way.
5. Candy Corn Fudge: An Easy Halloween Treat
Rich brown sugar chocolate fudge gets a layer of candy corn pressed on top. It takes about 10 minutes of hands-on time.
Kids love helping with this one. It’s perfect for Halloween parties and fall treat bags. Use red and green Christmas candy corn or pastel Easter candy corn, and it works for any holiday.
6. Fudge S’mores: S’mores Night Made Special
Swap the usual chocolate bar for a big, thick square of homemade fudge. Chocolate fudge and peanut butter fudge both work beautifully.
Set out a tray and let everyone build their own. It’s an easy way to make a campfire or a party feel special.
Making and Packaging Fudge to Give
Fudge is one of my favorite things to give at Christmas. Here’s how I make it ahead and get it ready to share.
- Line the pan with parchment. Leave extra hanging over the sides so you can lift the whole slab out for cutting.
- Cut it cold. Chilled fudge cuts into neat squares with a sharp knife.
- Make it ahead. Fantasy Fudge freezes well, so you can get a head start on your holiday baking.
A little packaging turns a pan of fudge into a gift people remember. Here’s what I like to use.
- Christmas tins: These square Christmas cookie tins hold a nice stack of fudge squares. They come in a set with lots of festive designs, so there’s one for everyone on your list.
- Treat boxes: A few squares in a treat box make a perfect gift for neighbors, teachers and friends.
- Cellophane bags: For smaller gifts, I tuck a few squares into self-sealing cellophane treat bags.
- Tags and bows: Finish it off with a kraft paper gift tag and one of these tiny velvet bows. Write the kind of fudge on the tag so everyone knows what’s inside!
Bonus: Hot Fudge Sauce
Not candy, but too good to leave out! My Hot Fudge Sauce comes together in about five minutes and is perfect over ice cream.
Ready to try your first candy thermometer recipe? My Easy Homemade Caramels are soft, chewy and the perfect next step after fudge.
Want an easy candy that doesn’t need a thermometer at all? My Peppermint Oreo Bark takes about 15 minutes of hands-on time and looks so festive in a clear gift bag.
What Fudge Recipe Will You Make First?
Whether you want a big pan for sharing, a no stove fudge for a busy night or something fun for the kids, there’s a recipe here for you. Pick one, make a pan and share it with someone you love this Christmas.






Leave a Reply